Skip to main content

The Cancer-Soy Connection Is Getting Less Confusing

There is perhaps no more complicated and fraught connection between cancer and food than the one between breast cancer and soy.


When studies first revealed that women in Asian countries who eat a significant amount of soy daily were less likely to die of breast cancer or experience recurrence than women who consumed less soy, many took it to mean that soy-based foods may have protective qualities. Other studies, meanwhile, found that soy may interfere with anti-cancer drugs, while others suggested that certain properties in soy mimic estrogen—which can fuel some breast cancers—and should therefore be avoided.



There's been plenty of back and forth, but new research helps to clear up the confusion. In the latest study on the subject, researchers led by Dr. Fang Fang Zhang, an assistant professor at the Friedman School of Nutrition Science and Policy at Tufts University, found that soy may not be so dangerous for women with breast cancer after all.


In the report published in the journal Cancer, Zhang and her colleagues found that women diagnosed with breast cancer who consumed more soy did not have a higher risk of dying over nine years than women who ate less. And among women with a certain type of breast cancer, soy actually lowered their risk of dying from any cause during that time.

As encouraging as the findings are, they aren’t enough to recommend that all women diagnosed with breast cancer start eating soy to prevent recurrences or early death, says Zhang. 


More studies need to confirm the trends she found, and to refine the dose of soy that’s optimal for preventing recurrences and early death. Still, it’s an important step toward better understanding the role that a food can play in cancer progression. “My take is that we should not recommend that women with breast cancer avoid soy,” she says. “Because we found no evidence to support that it’s harmful.”

Soy contains isoflavones, which act similarly to the hormone estrogen — and some breast cancers are driven by estrogen. When estrogen binds to breast cells, for example, it may trigger the cell to start growing out of control. But because soy-based estrogen is a weaker form of estrogen, some studies suggested that soy actually protected against breast cancer because the weaker isoflavones would take up space on breast cells and crowd out the more powerful cancer-causing estrogen from the body. On the other hand, there were also studies suggesting that isoflavones would sop up anti-estrogen drugs designed to shrink breast tumors and therefore leave cancers to grow.

So in her study, Zhang analyzed data from more than 6,200 women diagnosed with different types of breast cancer (those that were driven by estrogen and those that were not) who also reported on their diet. She also looked at the type of treatments the women received to see if their soy intake affected their response. She compared mortality rates to soy consumption, and found that women who ate more soy — a half to one serving a week — were 21% less likely to die of any cause over the study’s nine year follow up than women who ate less soy.

When Zhang broke down the data by the type of breast cancers the women had, and the treatments they received, there was even more reason to be encouraged. Women with breast cancers that were not driven by hormones—so-called estrogen and progesterone negative cancers—accounted for most of the drop in mortality. That makes sense, since soy mimics estrogen.

But even women who had estrogen- and progesterone-positive cancers weren’t apparently harmed by the soy. They did not enjoy a drop in mortality but they also did not experience an increase in deaths during the study, as previous work suggested. And those who were taking anti-estrogen drugs to treat their cancer also did not show any increase in mortality. That suggests that the soy wasn’t making the treatment ineffective, as earlier work had also indicated.

Zhang notes that compared to women in Asia, who eat about one to two servings a day, mostly in the form of tofu, women in the study, recruited from the U.S. and Canada, ate considerably less. So the results were encouraging since even at that lower amount of soy consumption, there appeared to be some benefit.

“It’s encouraging that despite the overall low consumption [of soy], women living in North America still benefit from increasing isoflavones,” she says.

source: time.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

lose weight No-exercise No-diet – super fast weight loss drink

To day in this post i will share with you A MAGICAL SLIMMING DRINK TO BURN FAT FAST.This Natural Drink to help SUPER FAST WEIGHT LOSS & also help to NO-EXERCISE NO-DIET WEIGHT LOSS FAST.

Top 10 Vitamin D Rich Foods

Vitamin D is a fat-soluble vitamin that is different from other vitamins because our bodies can make most of what we need with exposure to sunlight.

what do you need to eliminate sitting too long risks?

Another examination distributed in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology has uncovered that physical movement is significant for individuals who sit a ton. 
Office specialists who sit for significant lots of time can turn around the wellbeing dangers of their cutting edge inactive way of life by practicing only 20 minutes out of each day, another investigation uncovered on Tuesday. 
Distributed in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology, the University of Sydney-drove coordinated effort with the Norwegian School of Sport Sciences, Norwegian Institute of Public Health and the UK's Loughborough University inspected the wellbeing results related with sitting, reports Xinhua news organization. 
By measurably demonstrating physical action and sitting against the demise records of about 150,000 investigation members matured 45 years and over, the examination found "physical activity is especially significant for individuals who sit a great deal". 
"…

The Biggest Fat Burn Recipe Of All Time Is In Front Of You! You Can Lose 40 Pound In 1 Month

SINCE ANCIENT TIMES, NATURE HAS BEEN THE MAIN SOURCE OF MEDICINE FOR HUMANS. IN IT WE CAN FIND ALL THE PROPERTIES AND NUTRIENTS THAT WE NEED TO CURE MANY DISEASES.
That is why many have decided to leave conventional medicine aside to use natural medicine. The biggest advantage of this is that it is very cheap and it does not cause damage.

A natural drink used to treat many things is prepared with lemon and chia. This powerful beat helps us prevent the flu, cleanse the body and prevent fat build up . That is why many people around the world have decided to include it in their diet. If you also want to do it, we will show you how to prepare easily in your home.

Top 7 Weight Loss Tips Without Exercise or Diet

Today, I am going to share with you the tips to lose weight fast without any kind of exercise and dieting. Getting rid of extra body weight has become an issue of serious concern for the people all over the world. For this, people follow a number of methods and many of them do not work at all. For your help, here, I am going to share with you top five weight loss tips to lose weight without exercising and dieting.

However, there are several proven tips that can help you “mindlessly” eat fewer calories.

These are effective ways to reduce your weight, as well as to prevent weight gain in the future.